I’ve started this post more times than I’d like to admit. Every time, I find myself editing out a sentence because it tips too far one way – sounding too dismissive of diagnosis, or too uncritical of it. So this time I’m leaving the wobble in, because the wobble is the honest part.
Here’s what I actually think: a diagnosis of ADHD can be one of the most useful things that happens to a person. And also – at exactly the same time – I think we’ve built a culture that reaches for diagnosis before it’s finished asking questions. Both of those things are true, and I’m tired of conversations that force people to pick one.
What diagnosis genuinely gives people
I want to say this first and mean it fully, because I think the “critical” side of this debate sometimes forgets to.
For a lot of the young people and adults I work with, a diagnosis is the first time anyone has offered them a framework that isn’t “you’re lazy,” “you’re naughty,” or “you’re too much.” It gives language. It can open the door to reasonable adjustments at school or work that were refused without it. It can lift a weight of shame that’s been building for years, sometimes decades. I’ve sat with parents who cried with relief in an assessment room- not because their child had changed, but because someone in authority had finally said: this is real, and it isn’t your fault.
That relief matters. I’m not interested in a version of this conversation that treats it as naive or a fad. For plenty of people, diagnosis is the beginning of being met with felt safety for the first time, rather than correction.
What I can’t stop noticing, though
At the same time, I keep coming back to a question that won’t leave me alone: what happens to the inquiry once the label lands?
The numbers on this are hard to ignore. In England, prescriptions for ADHD medication rose by over 50% between 2019/20 and 2022/23, and adults aged 30 to 34 saw growth of around 146% – the steepest of any group. Autism referrals have followed a similar curve: open referrals for suspected autism rose more than fivefold between 2019 and 2023, and waiting times have stretched out to a median of over nine months for a first appointment, with some areas reporting waits of over two years. Something is genuinely shifting in how many of us are being assessed, and how quickly we reach for that assessment as the explanation.
Sami Timimi – a child and adolescent psychiatrist with nearly three decades of experience and a Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists – has spent his career arguing that psychiatry has, in his words, “commodified” distress. He argues that behaviours which might be entirely unremarkable in another culture or another decade are increasingly being read through a single medical lens. His point isn’t that ADHD doesn’t exist or that nobody should be diagnosed. It’s that diagnosis, once it arrives, can quietly close down every other question we might have asked about a person’s life: their environment, their relationships, their nervous system, and what they’ve lived through.
Dr Jessica Taylor makes a related but sharper argument, particularly about the surge in adult diagnoses among women: what looks like progress in recognition can also be pathologisation in disguise – turning ordinary variation, or the after-effects of trauma, into a permanent clinical identity, sometimes based on a TikTok video or a 20-minute private consultation.
I think about their arguments constantly, because they’re pointing at something I see in my own work.
How easy is too easy?
Part of what unsettles me is simply how fast this can move now. A private ADHD assessment in the UK can often be booked and completed within a few weeks of picking up the phone – compared with two to seven-plus years on an NHS waiting list, or six to twelve months even via NHS-funded Right to Choose routes. That speed comes at a cost, usually somewhere between £1,500 and £3,500 for diagnosis and initial treatment, and I don’t say that to suggest people are buying a diagnosis. Most private providers are genuinely thorough. But when one route takes years and another takes weeks, it changes who ends up in each queue, and it changes the incentives in the system as a whole.
Then there’s the version that doesn’t involve a clinician at all – a five-minute checklist shared on social media, ticking boxes that describe things almost every human being does sometimes: losing your keys, zoning out in a boring meeting, feeling restless. I understand the appeal. Those checklists can be the first nudge someone needs to seek a proper assessment. But they can also hand someone a whole identity before anyone has asked a single question about their sleep, their stress, their relationships, or what’s actually going on in their life right now.
Character, stage, or something more?
This is the question that sits underneath all of it for me, and it’s the hardest one: how do we tell the difference between “this is just who this child is,” “this is exactly where this child is developmentally,” and “this is something that needs support beyond what development and temperament will resolve on their own”?
Some of it is genuinely ordinary. A five-year-old who can’t sit still for twenty minutes, interrupts constantly, and forgets instructions three steps in isn’t showing symptoms – she’s being a five-year-old. Attention span, impulse control, and emotional regulation all mature enormously between early childhood and adolescence, and a huge amount of what gets flagged as “concerning” is simply a child who hasn’t finished growing yet.
There’s a piece of research I think about often here: children who are the youngest in their school year, purely by month of birth, are significantly more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD than their older classmates born earlier in the same academic year. That’s not a coincidence about who “has” ADHD – it’s a pattern in how we interpret behaviour. A child who is simply nine months less mature than the child next to them can look inattentive or impulsive by comparison, and the system reads that comparison as a symptom rather than as a stage.
None of that means ADHD isn’t real, or that every young child struggling to sit still is fine and needs nothing. Some children and adults are wired in a way that genuinely and persistently makes daily life harder – regardless of age, context, or how much support surrounds them – and pretending otherwise does real harm too. The line I try to hold is about persistence and context: does this show up everywhere, across settings and years, in a way that goes beyond what’s typical for this age and this stage? Or does it lift when the environment changes – a different classroom, more sleep, a calmer home, more connection? Character and developmental stage tend to move with context. A need that requires more structural support tends not to.
The bit that actually worries me
What worries me isn’t the diagnosis itself. It’s when the diagnosis becomes the whole story – when “they have ADHD” replaces “let’s find out what this child needs, in this body, in this family, in this classroom, right now.” A label can explain behaviour. It doesn’t always explain the why underneath the why – the dysregulated nervous system, the unmet need, the environment that’s asking more of someone than they can currently give.
I’ve worked with children who came to me already carrying a diagnosis, and when we slowed right down and looked at what was actually happening in their bodies and their relationships, we found things a label alone hadn’t captured: an unsafe home environment, an unprocessed loss, a classroom that had never once felt like a place to belong. None of that meant the diagnosis was wrong. It meant the diagnosis wasn’t finished being curious.
That’s really the heart of it for me. Diagnosis should be a door, not a full stop.
Holding both at once
So where does that leave me, practically? Somewhere unglamorous: I think diagnosis and inquiry are not in competition. A young person can have ADHD and be carrying trauma that shapes how it shows up. An adult can be diagnosed and still benefit enormously from someone asking what happened to them, not just what’s wrong with them. Getting assessed doesn’t need to be the end of the conversation about context – it can be the beginning of a much more layered one.
This is why, in my own practice, a diagnosis (existing or pending) never changes the starting question: what does this person’s nervous system need in order to feel safe enough to grow? Connection before correction applies whether or not there’s a diagnostic label attached to the behaviour in front of me. The label might tell me something useful about how someone’s brain processes attention, time, or stimulation. It won’t tell me about their history, their relationships, or what safety has or hasn’t felt like for them. That part still has to be built, person by person.
Where I’d like the debate to go
I’d love for this conversation to stop being fought as diagnosis-is-good versus diagnosis-is-overused, because I don’t think either side, taken alone, is being honest about what people actually need. I’d rather we asked: how do we make sure a diagnosis – when it’s right – comes with a proper look at context, relationships, and nervous system regulation, rather than instead of one? How do we build assessment pathways that have time to be curious, in a system where waiting lists already stretch past a year before anyone’s even in the room?
I don’t have a tidy answer. I’m not sure there is one. But I’d rather sit in that uncomfortable middle, genuinely undecided about some of it, than hand anyone – a parent, a young person, a fellow professional – a slogan instead of the truth.
If you’re navigating this for your own child, or in your own life, and you want a space to think it through without being pushed toward a predetermined answer, that’s exactly the kind of conversation we hold at The Life Skills Mentoring Academy. Get in touch – we’re happy to talk it through.



