How many times have you heard it? From a GP, a friend, a TV advert, maybe even said it to yourself: “My brain just doesn’t make enough serotonin.”
For many people this explanation brought real relief. It said: this isn’t your fault, it’s biology. You wouldn’t blame someone for diabetes, so why blame yourself for depression?
But what if that story was never quite true? And what if, by believing it, we stopped asking the question that matters most: what happened to you?
Where the story came from
The idea that low serotonin causes depression began as a hypothesis in the 1960s. It went mainstream from the 1990s, when a new generation of antidepressants (SSRIs) arrived and the link was widely publicised.
Bestselling books such as Listening to Prozac spread the news of SSRIs’ apparently miraculous effects, which seemed to confirm the theory. Professional bodies echoed drug company messaging too; one American Psychiatric Association patient leaflet from 2005 suggested antidepressants may be prescribed to correct imbalances in brain chemicals.
It stuck. Surveys from the 2000s found that 88% of people in Australia and 85% in the US believed depression was caused by a chemical imbalance. Even more telling, among 237 psychology students interviewed, 46% had heard the chemical imbalance explanation directly from a doctor.
What Professor Joanna Moncrieff found
In 2022, Professor Joanna Moncrieff, a consultant psychiatrist and professor at University College London, led a team that pulled together decades of research into one “umbrella review”, a review of the existing reviews.
Researchers over the years had looked at serotonin in blood and spinal fluid, brain imaging of serotonin receptors, genetic studies, and experiments that deplete the building blocks of serotonin. If low serotonin caused depression, these should consistently show deficits. They didn’t. The review concluded there was no consistent evidence linking serotonin and depression, and no support for the idea that depression is caused by lower serotonin levels or activity.
There’s a comparison that helps here. Just because a medication reduces symptoms doesn’t mean the symptoms were caused by the problem the drug corrects. Aspirin eases headaches, but headaches aren’t caused by a lack of aspirin.
So how do antidepressants work?
This is where Moncrieff’s work gets really interesting, and more contested. She proposes what she calls a “drug-centred” model. Rather than correcting a faulty brain, she suggests antidepressants create an altered state that can reduce how intensely people feel things. She believes they produce emotional blunting, which numbs both positive and negative emotions and so reduces the intensity of depressed feelings.
She compares this to how people taking opiates for pain sometimes say the pain is still there, but they no longer care about it as much.
Importantly, Moncrieff isn’t saying no one should ever take an antidepressant. Her position is that people deserve to make an informed choice, knowing what trials show about benefit, knowing the full range of possible side effects, and being clear that the chemical imbalance idea isn’t supported by evidence.
Many people I speak to recognise that “numbed” or “flat” description. Others say medication gave them just enough breathing space to start doing the deeper work. Both experiences are valid.
Holding the uncomfortable middle
It would be easy to make this a “psychiatry got it all wrong” post. That wouldn’t be honest, and it wouldn’t be helpful.
Many experts pushed back hard on the review. Some argued that the simple “low serotonin = depression” theory had already been considered outdated for decades within the field. A group of 36 experts argued the review misrepresented some findings and wrongly cast doubt on antidepressants without presenting evidence, maintaining that antidepressants are effective for people with clinically significant depression. Other critics argue that Moncrieff’s drug-centred model relies on beliefs that don’t have widespread scientific support.
So here’s where I land. Antidepressants help some people, and that matters. The science of the brain is genuinely complicated and still unfolding. But if the profession moved on from the chemical imbalance story years ago, as one commentator put it, psychiatry forgot to tell the public. And many people built their whole understanding of themselves around it.
Why the story isn’t harmless
You might think: does it matter, if it helped people feel less to blame?
Research suggests it does. In one experiment, people with a history of depression were given a fake but convincing “brain chemistry test”. Those told their depression was caused by a chemical imbalance didn’t feel any less self-blame. Instead, they felt more pessimistic about recovery, less confident they could manage their own mood, and saw medication as more credible than therapy.
Think about that. The story meant to relieve shame didn’t. What it did do was quietly tell people that change was out of their hands, and that talking, connection and understanding their own story were less likely to help.
What Dr Jessica Taylor asks us to notice
This is where Dr Jessica Taylor’s work comes in, and why it matters so much to how we work. Dr Taylor is a Chartered Psychologist with a PhD in Forensic Psychology, and has spent more than a dozen years working with women and girls subjected to abuse and trauma.
In Sexy But Psycho, she asks why women who report violence are so likely to be diagnosed with personality disorders, and how so many women came to believe they were mentally ill for having normal reactions to traumatic experiences. Her argument is that every behaviour, thought or feeling after trauma is either a response to what happened, a way of coping with it, or both. That includes nightmares, flashbacks, self-harm, and withdrawing from people for years.
She also highlights something painful: for women diagnosed with borderline personality disorder, speaking out about it can simply get them labelled as attention-seeking, unreliable or manipulative.
Not everyone agrees with all of Dr Taylor’s conclusions, and she’s a deliberately provocative writer. But her central question is one I see play out in practice again and again. When we locate the problem in someone’s brain chemistry, we can stop looking at what happened to them, and at the people and systems responsible.
What happened to you? And a word of caution about ACEs
We have strong evidence that life experiences shape our mental health. The best-known research here is the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) study, which found that adults with four or more ACEs had a 12 times higher prevalence of health risks including depression and suicide attempts.
Closer to home, a large UK study following children in Bristol from before birth found that sexual abuse and adversities involving physical and emotional threat, especially in adolescence, had the strongest links to depression in young adulthood.
But having just challenged one oversimplified story, it would be unfair not to challenge another. Because the ACE study is now being used in ways it was never designed for.
What the ACE study actually was
The original study ran from 1995 to 1997 with more than 17,000 adults, who were members of a health insurance scheme in San Diego. After a routine physical exam, they completed confidential surveys about their childhood experiences and their current health.
It was a population research study. It looked at patterns across thousands of people, looking backwards at what they remembered. It was never designed to be a checklist for individual children or families.
The sample also wasn’t representative. Most participants were middle to upper income, 69% were white, and 74% had attended college. Later studies with other groups have found similar patterns, but the original findings came from a very specific population.
What the study’s own authors say
This is the part I find most powerful. In 2020, Dr Robert Anda, one of the original lead researchers, co-authored a paper warning against misuse of the ACE score. He and his co-authors describe the score as a relatively crude measure of childhood stress that can vary widely from person to person.
They make clear that the score is not suitable for screening individuals and assigning risk for decision-making, and that it is neither diagnostic nor predictive for any one person. The other lead researcher, Dr Vincent Felitti, has written that the questionnaire is neither a comprehensive nor a diagnostic clinical tool.
In other words, the people who created the ACE score are telling us: please don’t use it to label individuals.
Why that matters
It counts, but it doesn’t understand. A score adds up events, but it doesn’t capture how intense, frequent or long-lasting they were. Two children with the same score can have completely different experiences. It also weights every adversity equally, which isn’t how trauma works.
It leaves things out. The original list focuses on what happens inside the home. Researcher David Finkelhor has shown that experiences such as bullying, racism and community violence can be as traumatic as, or more traumatic than, some of the original ACEs. None of these are on the original list.
It can hide poverty and inequality. One of the main criticisms is that its individual focus can lead us to overlook socioeconomic conditions. Poverty and unemployment are among the strongest predictors of child maltreatment. When we focus on individual families’ “scores”, we risk blaming families for problems that are rooted in wider social injustice.
It can become another label. This is where it connects back to Dr Jessica Taylor’s work. A child described as “high ACEs” can quickly become a child people expect less from, or see as damaged. One social justice critique warns against treating children, families and communities as both the cause of complex social problems and the solution to them.
It doesn’t predict outcomes for any individual. Research shows the ACE score alone doesn’t accurately tell us who will and won’t go on to have poor health later in life. Many people with high scores do well, and the relationships, safety and support around a child make a huge difference.
So how do we use this research well?
The ACE study did something genuinely important. It helped shift public conversation towards how childhood experiences shape our health. That shift is part of why trauma-informed practice exists at all.
The problem isn’t the research. It’s turning population statistics into a number stamped on a child.
What about children and young people?
This is the part that matters most to me, given who we work with.
The number of 12 to 17 year olds prescribed antidepressants in England more than doubled between 2005 and 2017, yet antidepressants are not usually recommended as a first treatment for under-18s because of limited evidence on their safety and effectiveness in young people. The rise was sharpest among teenage girls from 15 to 17.
I’m not saying any individual prescription is wrong. Every family’s situation is different, and some young people are in real crisis. But when a teenager is struggling, it’s worth asking what their nervous system has been living through. Bullying? Family breakdown? Exam pressure? Online harm? Something they haven’t been able to tell anyone yet?
A child’s distress is communication. When we treat it only as a chemical problem, or reduce it to a score, we risk missing the message.
From “What’s wrong with you?” to “What’s happened to you?”
Here in the UK, the British Psychological Society funded the Power Threat Meaning Framework. Co-produced by psychologists and people with lived experience and launched in 2018, it argues that emotional distress and troubled behaviour make sense when viewed in the context of a person’s life, the expectations placed on them, and their exposure to trauma, abuse, injustice and inequality.
It invites us to ask different questions: What has happened to you? How did it affect you? What sense did you make of it? What did you have to do to survive?
That’s the heart of it. Distress is not a broken brain. Very often it’s a nervous system doing exactly what it learned to do to keep someone safe. Hypervigilance, shutting down, anger, numbness: these can all be survival responses that made complete sense at the time, even if they’re costly now.
What this does NOT mean
Please hear this part clearly. This is not a message to stop taking medication.
The Royal College of Psychiatrists advises that antidepressants should not usually be stopped suddenly, as this can cause withdrawal symptoms and increase the chance of becoming unwell again. NICE guidance now advises reducing the dose in stages, with smaller steps as the dose gets lower, and slowing or pausing if withdrawal symptoms appear. Withdrawal effects are now recognised as more common, and sometimes more severe and long-lasting, than was previously understood.
If you’re thinking about changing your medication, talk to your prescriber first.
Medication and a trauma-informed understanding aren’t enemies. You can take an antidepressant and deserve someone who asks what happened to you.
Questions worth sitting with
If this blog has stirred something up, here are some gentle questions to reflect on, or to take to your GP or practitioner:
- What was happening in my life when I started feeling this way?
- Has anyone ever asked me about my history, or just my symptoms?
- What was I told about why I feel this way, and how did that explanation make me feel about my future?
- If I take medication, do I understand what it’s doing, its possible side effects, and how I’d come off it safely one day?
- What else might help alongside or instead: connection, safety, therapy, rest, support with what’s actually going on?
How we work at TLSMA
Our work starts from felt safety and connection, not from finding what’s “wrong”. Whether we’re working with a child, a young person or a parent, we’re curious about the story underneath the behaviour, because when we understand the story, the behaviour usually starts to make sense.
We don’t score children. We listen to them. We’re interested in their whole story, including what’s happened to them, what’s happening around them, and crucially what has helped them feel safe and connected.
Sometimes that looks like Drawing and Talking with a young child. Sometimes it’s therapeutic coaching with a teenager who’s been told they’re “just anxious”. Sometimes it’s helping a parent see their child’s meltdown as a nervous system in overwhelm rather than defiance. Always, it’s connection before correction.
You were never just a chemical imbalance, and you were never just a score. You’re a person with a history, and your history matters.



